EXHIBIT 14-A

OPTIONS FOR DIVESTING or CONTINUING DISTRICT PROGRAM

FOR RESCUE AND REARING OF THREATENED STEELHEAD

IN THE CARMEL RIVER

Option or Scenario

MPWMD CEQA Action

MPWMD Actions Needed

Risks and Consequences

 

Contracts  & Cost

Challenge SCD CEQA Review

Litigate SCD CEQA Review

ESA Violation

Cal-Am Production

1.      Continue Operation, with Interim Retrofit

Notice of Exemption

YES

JFO/CDM

($145,000)

Amendment

Possible

Possible

Moderate-High Risk to Fish at Facility

No Change, 11,285 AF

2.  Continue Operation, with Permanent Retrofit

Notice of Exemption

YES

JFO/CDM

($506,773)

Possible

Possible

Low Risk at Facility

No Change, 11,285 AF

3.  Transfer Program to Another Entity, Cal-Am, CDFG, NOAA FISHERIES

Mitigated Negative Declaration

NO

NA

NA

Low to High Risk Depending on Retrofit/Sediment

Possible Reduction to Minimize Take

4. Shutdown Program & Mothball Facility

Allocation, EIR Supplement

NO

NA

NA

High Risk in Lower River

Possible Reduction to Minimize Take

5.  Shutdown Program & Decommission & Remove Facility

Allocation, EIR Supplement

NO

NA

NA

High Risk in Lower River

Possible Reduction to Minimize Take

U:\staff\word\boardpacket\2003\2003boardpacket\20030227\ActionItems\14\item14_exh14a.doc